Sad State of Indian Diet: Lack of contextual Scientific rigor
In the olden days, our grandmothers didn't have gym memberships or "diet charts." They didn't know about calories or "macros." Yet, they were strong, active, and rarely visited the hospital. Today, we have smartwatches, super-specialty hospitals on every corner, and apps telling us what to eat. But look around. are we healthy? No. We are becoming the Diabetes Capital of the world.
Why is this happening? It is simple. We have systematically degraded our food habits because we are not doing research on our food habits, we are dependent on west to tell us what to eat and what not to eat. But we are forgetting one basic truth: Food must be according to the location and the work we do. Our obsession for Stanford, Cambridge , MIT etc. doesn’t work for food. To add further , we are ignoring research done here by ancestors labeling some of those as old beliefs almost like black magic not science. We are not spending enough to research by ourselves
A Problem We Don't Discuss
We have a major problem in India that doctors call the "Asian Indian Phenotype" or the "Thin-Fat" body. Even if we look thin from the outside, our bodies are storing fat inside, around the liver and organs.
In the West, people can store fat under their skin. But our genetics are different; we are prone to diabetes much faster. We are simply copying their diet without realizing our bodies are wired differently. We need research on our bodies, not data from a study done on people in America or Europe.
Why "One Diet Fits All" is a Lie
We must understand that geography dictates biology. You cannot put a polar bear in the desert and expect it to survive on camel food. Similarly, you cannot live in tropical South India and eat like a European.
1. Our Gut is different: Prevotella vs. Bacteroides
We are not just different on the outside; we are different on the inside too. Scientific research shows that Indian guts are dominated by a bacteria called Prevotella, which is evolved to digest plant fibers, carbohydrates, and grains. The Western gut is dominated by Bacteroides, which is better at handling high protein and animal fats. When we blindly copy the West and start stuffing ourselves with heavy meats or processed proteins, our Prevotella gut gets confused and inflamed. We are literally fighting our own biology.
2. Weather vs. Food: The Russia Logic
Think about Russia or Northern Europe. The temperature there drops to -20°C. To survive that bone-chilling cold, their bodies need immense internal heat. That is why Vodka or heavy spirits might be necessary there—to keep the blood warm and preventing freezing. Now look at us in South India. It is 35°C to 45°C. Our bodies are already overheated. If you drink Vodka or heavy alcohol here, you are just dehydrating yourself and damaging your liver. Yet, we think it is "cool" to copy them. We are adding fuel to the fire.
3. Even Within India: The North vs. South Mistake
We don't even need to go as far as Russia. Look at the difference between North and South India.
The North (Heat Generation): In Delhi or Punjab, winters drop to 2°C or 3°C. Their body needs heat to survive. That is why they eat Wheat (Roti) and cook in Mustard Oil. Mustard oil is naturally heating. It keeps them warm.
The South (Heat Management): In Chennai or Vijayawada, we are living in a tropical oven. We don't need to generate heat; we need to manage it. Nature gave us Rice and Coconut because they are cooling. Kerala uses Coconut oil because it cools the system.
The Blunder: Now, because of TV and YouTube, a South Indian person starts cooking in Mustard Oil or eating only Wheat Rotis thinking it is "healthier." What happens? You are putting a heater inside a body that is already hot! This leads to acidity, skin issues, and piles. The food that is "nectar" for a Punjabi can be "poison" for a Tamilian if the weather doesn't match.
4. The "Agni" (Digestion) Factor
In cold countries, the body's digestive fire (Agni) works very hard to generate heat. They can digest raw salads, cold smoothies, and heavy cheeses. In our hot and humid climate, our body draws energy away from digestion to keep the skin cool (sweating). Our digestion is naturally softer.
The Mistake: We are eating ice-cold smoothie bowls and raw salads because an influencer in Los Angeles did it.
The Result: Our sensitive digestion cannot break it down, leading to bloating and gut issues. Our ancestors knew this—that is why they ate cooked, warm food that is easy to digest.
Food is Work Specific
In the olden days, our ancestors worked hard in the fields under the hot sun. Their food was designed for that life. They ate Ambali (fermented porridge) and Jonna Rotte (Sorghum) or Ragi Mudda. These gave slow energy.
Now: We sit in AC offices for 10 hours, hardly moving, but we are eating polished white rice three times a day.
Oats vs. Millets: Why are we eating Oats that grow in cold Scotland? We have our own "Siridhanya" (Millets) like Korra (Foxtail) and Arikelu (Kodo) that grow in our dry lands. They are far superior to oats for our body, yet we ignore them because oats have better marketing.
Another area where we have completely lost our way is cooking oil.
Olden Days: Our grandmothers used "Ghanuga Nune" (Bull-driven Cold Pressed Oil). Whether it was Groundnut oil in Rayalaseema or Sesame oil in Telangana, it was thick, golden, and full of aroma. It had natural antioxidants that protected our heart.
The "Refined" Trap: Then came the Western influence and big marketing saying traditional oil is bad. We switched to "Refined" Sunflower or Rice Bran oils. We thought "Refined" meant superior, but in reality, it means "chemically stripped." These oils are washed with Hexane (a chemical), bleached, and deodorized until they are just empty liquid plastic.
The Olive Oil Mistake: Now, the rich people are using Olive Oil for Indian cooking to copy the Italians. But research shows Olive Oil has a low smoke point. When you use it for our Indian Tadka or deep frying, it burns and becomes toxic (carcinogenic). It is good for salads in Italy, not for Pesarattu in Andhra. We are literally burning our health in expensive oil.
The "Vegetarian" Confusion
This is the biggest tragedy happening right now. Many people are thinking, "Oh, I am feeling weak, vegetarian food has no protein, I lack vitamins," and they are starting to eat eggs or chicken.
This is fixing the problem in the wrong way.
The problem is not that vegetarian food is bad. The problem is that we have corrupted vegetarian food.
A proper South Indian meal was never just a mountain of white rice. It was millets, plenty of Pappu (dal), and nutrient-dense greens. Now, we eat 90% polished rice (which is just sugar basically) and 10% curry. Of course, you will lack vitamins!
Missing Superfoods: We have forgotten our own superfoods. Take Gongura for example. It is rich in Iron and Vitamin C. Science says Vitamin C helps absorb Iron. Our ancestors combined them perfectly. But we are leaving Gongura and eating foreign vegetables like Broccoli or Lettuce which don't suit our soil.
Vegetarian food has its own purpose. It keeps the body cool and the mind clear (Sattvic). But you cannot survive on just white rice and potato fry. You need the Ambali, the Gongura, the Muntamamidikaya (Cashew fruit), and the Panasa (Jackfruit).
The "Lost Foods" of Andhra: What We Forgot
In our rush to eat Pizza and Burgers, we have completely forgotten the gems of our own land. These were not just "food items"; they were medicine.
Saraswati Aku (Brahmi): Today, we force our kids to swallow "Memory Pills" during exams. But our grandmothers simply added Saraswati Aku (Brahmi) into the Rasam or made a Thambuli (chutney) with it. It wasn't "medicine time," it was "lunch time." That is how they kept their memory sharp without doing Sudoku puzzles.
Nalleru (Veld Grape): This creeper looks like a cactus, but it is the best thing for bones. If someone had a fracture in the village, they were given Nalleru Pachadi. Now we just take Calcium tablets and complain about knee pain at age 30.
Ulava Charu (Horse Gram Soup): Today, we run to the pharmacy for kidney stones. In the olden days, people drank Ulava Charu. It is heat-generating and known to flush out toxins. It is high protein without the heaviness of meat. But now? We only see it in weddings, that too made with artificial cream.
Chintachiguru (Tender Tamarind Leaves): When summer starts, nature gives us these tangy leaves. They are packed with Vitamin C and antioxidants. Our grandmothers made Pappu (dal) with it to beat the heat. Now, we are popping Vitamin C tablets but ignoring the leaves falling in our backyard.
Munagaku (Drumstick Leaves): We eat the drumstick but throw away the leaves! Munagaku is a superfood with more Vitamin A than carrots. It was fry-cooked with Moong dal. Now it is just goat feed.
Tegalu (Palmyra Sprouts): You might see these being sold on carts in villages. These are pure fiber. They clean the gut like a broom. But modern kids are eating processed chips that stick to the gut, while Tegalu are considered "village food."
Kanda Bachali (Elephant Yam & Spinach): This is a classic combination. The Yam (Kanda) provides good carbs, and the Bachali (Malabar Spinach) provides cooling. It was the perfect balance. Now we just eat Aloo Fry which is nothing but gas and starch.
We Didn't Just Change the Food, We Changed the Method
It is not just what we eat, but how we cook it. We sacrificed health for 5 minutes of convenience.
The Death of the 'Rolu' (Stone Grinder)
In the olden days, chutney was made on a Rolu or Roke. The stone ground the ingredients slowly. This kept the ingredients cool and retained the essential oils and the taste. Now: We throw everything into a high-speed Mixer Grinder. The blades rotate at 5000 RPM! This generates heat (friction), which literally cooks the chutney while grinding. You are killing the live enzymes and the good bacteria before you even eat it. The taste is gone, so we add more salt and sugar to fix it.
Vessels of Convenience (and Poison)
Clay Pots (Matti Kunda): These were porous. They allowed heat to circulate evenly and neutralized the acidity in the food. The food tasted sweet naturally.
Iron Kadai: Cooking in iron gave us a daily dose of Iron supplement naturally. Anemia was rare.
The Modern Disaster: We threw these away because they were "hard to clean." We brought in Non-Stick (which is basically coating your food with plastic/Teflon) and Aluminium (which leaches into food and is toxic). We are eating poison slowly every day just so we don't have to scrub a pan.
The Way Forward: Balance, Not Blindness
We have to agree on one thing: society has changed. We don't do the same work as our ancestors, and we don't live in independent houses with big backyards anymore. We live in apartments, we have sophisticated automation, and we have busy lives. So, we simply cannot take the past and paste it here. That is impossible.
Instead, we need to do three specific things:
1. Adapt the Past (Education & Advertisement)
We need to take the right things from the past and apply them where we can. This needs massive education. Why is Kale marketed as a superfood but Gongura is just a "pickle leaf"? We need to advertise our own science.
2. Active Local Research (Stop the Suicide Mission)
Depending on the West to tell us how to fix our problems is suicidal. They research for their context, their weather. We need active research here to build the right equipment and practices for current society. If clay pots are too hard to clean for a working woman, let our engineers invent a "Modern Clay Pot" that is durable and dishwasher safe but still porous. We need innovation for us.
3. Keep an Open Mind (Logic over Emotion)
We must understand that not everything in the past is Gold. At the same time, not every modern science paper is the Truth (Especially in food). Some people think "Grandma was not scientific." That is wrong; her science was practical. But also, do not think "Everything Grandma said is Gold." She might have had some superstitions too.
The Rule: Apply logic. Understand what is right for you, your body, and your lifestyle. Don't be a slave to tradition OR trend. Be a master of your own health.
Comments
Post a Comment